It’s not so easy when it’s your Dad

When I was in seminary, I took a class on medical ethics. I loved it and said that if I was younger and was looking for a different career, I’d love to be an ethicist. Reading the case studies and applying the principles and practices was a stimulating and enjoyable exercise and I loved the challenge of seeking the best outcome for the theoretical situations we were presented with. But, that was then, and this is now.

Fast forward half a decade….now I am faced with finding my way through the labyrinth of being the sole caregiver for my aging father who is suffering multiple maladies including (but not only) congestive heart failure and Lewy Bodies Dementia with Parkinsonism. Even though the time hasn’t quite come, I am now facing the prospect of enacting his Enduring Power of Attorney and possibly his Personal Directive. His dementia is advancing and he has become more focused on his day to day comfort and losing the ability to consider the long term repercussions of the choices he is making. The question is one of how much choice should he be given?

Here is the situation: As the congestive heart failure worsens, he is retaining more and more fluid. His legs swell quite severely, his becomes short of breath and quite weak. Lasix controls the symptoms very effectively but result in some urinary urgency, which is likely worsened by chronic constipation (I’ve read that this can be a symptom of Parkinsons). Because he is finding it more and more difficult to move quickly, often he is unable to reach the bathroom and pees his pants. Of course, he is overcome with shame and distress at this. For him, the humiliation of peeing his pants at 86, takes higher precedence over the long term consequences of not taking the drug.
Adding to his shame and embarassment is the effects of the constipation that has developed over time. Although the reading I’ve done indicates that it could be a result of the Parkinsonism that goes with Lewy Bodies, so far the docs haven’t spoken about that. He has suffered from chronic constipation for years, and has been dependent on stool softeners and laxatives for as long as 15 years. (note to self: eat lots of roughage, get lots of exercise and drink lots of water). Now, he seems to be unable to move his bowels on his own and takes laxatives daily, which results in occasional explosive results. Again, he is humiliated and embarrassed by this. He blames the diuretic for all of his incontinence issues and is now refusing to take it.

The mental deterioration complicates the matter. Lewy Bodies Dementia is a type of dementia where the patients mental acuity can change from day to day, and even from hour to hour. It is quite possible to be in the midst of a conversation with Dad where he is making perfect sense, when suddenly, he’s off in a totally different direction and not making any sense at all. When this happens, he gets angry and defensive and often accuses me of intentionally trying to confuse him. He finds it difficult to make decisions especially if there are multiple concepts and ideas to deal with. Obviously, this isn’t someone who is capable of making a reasoned, well-thought out decision regarding his health.

Dad has always had a horror and fear of dementia. He has been highly critical of and sometimes even rude towards people with dementia. He seems to see it as a moral failing rather than a chemical or physical issue. I know that this attitude isn’t uncommon among people of his generation. Often when discussing or observing people with dementia, he has commented to me: “Don’t ever let me get like that.” And now, he is quickly becoming his worst fear. Although I’ve been aware of his failing mental acuity over the past 5 years, it is becoming more and more obvious to others and recently the diagnosis has been made.

The ethical question for me is one of whether or not I, or his physicians should be forcing, or tricking him into taking a drug that is causing him such humiliation and distress. Even though not taking the drug will certainly shorten his life, and may indeed cause him pain and illness from the swelling and gathering of fluid in his chest cavity, who should be making this decision? Is it his to make, is it mine, is it the doctors? What is worse for him, heart failure or dementia? Do we prolong his life only to have the dementia worsen? Do we allow him to make choices that (he believes) will solve his problem (even in the short term), even though they might shorten his life? How do we even discuss this?

About theladyfather

Anglican Priest of an ethnically diverse small city parish.
This entry was posted in Caregiving. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to It’s not so easy when it’s your Dad

  1. Oh, dear friend. I have no answers, but only prayers for you in this situation. May you hear God’s voice surely and clearly. May you be comforted by your love for him, even when it all seems impossible.

  2. Susan Ormsbee says:

    I think that the hardest situations are those concerning your own parents; the change in who takes responsibility for decisions is difficult. When my Dad started to suffer from dementia I was not very involved as Mom took over the decision making; the hardest part was to offer her support in the process. It was very different when Mom decided that she would no longer make decisions and left everything up to me. As the only child it was sad to know that she was getting weaker due to the decisions that I made BUT it was also sweet when she said how happy she was to still be in her room and
    not in the hospital or chronic care facility. Through all this time, in prayer and quiet times I heard God’s calming voice and I also heard Mom talk about
    feeling his love for her. My prayer for you is that you will hear God’s voice and experience his love as you journey through this difficult time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s